I have been able to get my M-Audio Oxygen8 and Evolution UC-33 (MIDI knob & slider box) to work pretty well with Logic's MIDI Learn (in Controller Assignments). But, I am unable to get my M-Audio Ozonic to work with Logic's MIDI Learn. The same problem happens on my Nord Lead which is connected to my G5 via the MOTU Fastlane USB MIDI Interface.
The same problem also happens with Logic's Automation Quick Access.
Either in the Controller Assignments window or in Automation Quick access, when I activate MIDI Learn and move a knob on the Ozonic or Nord Lead, it appears to be Learning (it sees the knob and shows the CC # properly).
Then it just doesn't work.
When I MIDI Learn in Reaktor, it works immediately, everytime from both the Ozonic and the Nord. Same with Reason. When I Edit "Remote Override Mapping", it works perfect. That's how I know the Ozonic and Nord are in the proper mode and working as they should.
Also, I know Logic is seeing the Ozonic and Nord Lead's CC knobs because the Ozonic's 1st knob and last slider automatically control the selected track's Pan & Volume (respectively). The Nord's Amp Gain also controls the selected track's Volume. No other CC's on either device -except obviously Pitch Bend and Mod Whl- are able to be mapped to Logic's MIDI Learn.
When I Logic's Event List, I can see which CC is being received from the Ozonic and Nord, so I know, for example: The Nord's Filt Cutoff and Res are transmitting 71 & 74 (as they should) to Logic.
I just downloaded MIDI Monitor and plan to use it tomorrow to see exactly which Controllers are being transmitted from the Ozonic/Nord and perhaps I'll figure out how to manually configure it.
Even after reading the section of the manual over and over that shows how to do this, the Expert View of Logic's Controller Assignments has quite a few settings that are still over my head to some extent.
I have been told it should work with any MIDI Controller (even "unsupported" ones), but I am not having any luck... anyone think I'm missing something???