Jump to content

Mic or Preamp?


Recommended Posts

Hey everyone

I have been recordings songs for over 11 years now and always was poor and had to get the cheapest equipment

I now have some money to spend but i need help

I bought an Audio-Technica AT3035 (mic) and i'm using the M-Audio Firewire Solo

I want to improve my sound quality my budget is less than $600

Should I use all the money for a preamp or should i upgrade the mic and get a preamp, or spend it all on a mic?

 

I've been doing literally hours of research and can't find the answer I'm looking for

So if anyone has any suggestions that would be Awesome!!

 

I do mostly youtube video commentaries. I have almost 12,000 subscribers here is a link http://www.youtube.com/epicgamerworld

and i do a little rap here is a link with some of my songs http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=1059460&content=music

 

Thanks guys i appreciate it!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can definitely get a better mic pre. I strongly recommend the Golden Age Pre 73. It's amazing for what you pay.

Personally I like the Shure KSM27 for vocals. But definitely get the mic pre first.

 

Ok thanks. Someone said that I should replace my m-audio device with a Usbpre instead of spending the money on a preamp..

 

Does this make sense??? I now have around $1,000 to spend and want to spend it on a preamp then upgrade my mic later.

Will the m-audio interface affect the sound quality if I use an expensive preamp or will it affect it at all?

 

Any info would be awesome!!!

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Should I use all the money for a preamp or should i upgrade the mic and get a preamp, or spend it all on a mic?

 

I've been doing literally hours of research and can't find the answer I'm looking for

So if anyone has any suggestions that would be Awesome!!

Look no further. It's a trick question...

 

In order of priority (apart from a good performance and an engineer who knows what he's doing):

 

1. Acoustic treatment of your recording room

2. Microphone

3. Preamp

4. Compressor

5. Sound card

 

Acoustic treatment includes an acoustic ceiling and bass traps. It does not include any foam products or microphone shields.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

In order of priority (apart from a good performance and an engineer who knows what he's doing):

 

1. Acoustic treatment of your recording room

2. Microphone

3. Preamp

4. Compressor

5. Sound card

 

Good info. Ive heard that a preamp is more important because even with an expensive mic it can only sound as good as the preamp. Im kinda new to all this, so this is just what I've learned the last few days

I heard a good preamp can make a $100 mic sound like a $1,000 mic without a preamp.

 

Anyways... will I be wasting my money on a good preamp with the m-audio device I have?

really what i want to know is will it affect the sound at all that will be noticeable?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I heard a good preamp can make a $100 mic sound like a $1,000 mic without a preamp.

That's a load of poppycock, I'm afraid. Also, a mic won't work without a preamp.

 

While it's true that a preamp will affect the signal from the microphone, a preamp is only a small part of the equation and much less so than the microphone itself.

 

In fact there's surprisingly little difference between most solid state preamps and sound cards (converters), but the same can't be said for microphones.

 

If you have an untreated room that'll be the biggest hurdle. You can partly compensate in the mix for the frequency changes a microphone and preamp impose on your recording, but the time domain problems from a untreated room can't be fixed.

 

Anyways... will I be wasting my money on a good preamp with the m-audio device I have?

really what i want to know is will it affect the sound at all that will be noticeable?

Unless you treat your room correctly first: no, that's very unlikely.

 

Listening to your video clips, it sounds more like you need to work out how to equalize and compress your voice better in the mix. Also, some volume automation or sidechain ducking would help in the video commentaries.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Good info. Ive heard that a preamp is more important because even with an expensive mic it can only sound as good as the preamp. Im kinda new to all this, so this is just what I've learned the last few days

I heard a good preamp can make a $100 mic sound like a $1,000 mic without a preamp.

 

Anyways... will I be wasting my money on a good preamp with the m-audio device I have?

really what i want to know is will it affect the sound at all that will be noticeable?

 

For now, don't spend your money on anything (no need to read any more beyond this point).

 

There is more to all this and cannot be answered with a simple "get this or that."

 

Your M-Audio box has a spec sheet: http://www.m-audio.com/images/global/manuals/FWSolo_UG_EN01.pdf

 

As does your mic: http://www.audio-technica.com/cms/resource_library/literature/1677ce82695ff2f5/at3035_english.pdf

 

As does something like an Avalon VT-737SP: http://www.avalondesign.com/vt737sp.html

 

 

 

At first, you would think that everything will work with anything. It will, but after a while you will start to notice you can do better.

 

There is a reason the very expensive (insert item) sounds superior to the cheap $99 version of that same model. You don't want to send your very expensive mic that goes thru an expensive pre amp into a $99 audio interface.

 

Basically, you do not want a weak link in the audio chain. So the spec sheet has some important info regarding what equipment can work well or better than other equipment.

 

So in terms of what you are hearing in your head and what your ears hear, you want to make a drastic improvement, but you can't afford that kind of equipment right now.

 

You can buy less expensive toys that will give you a great sound on an amateur level, but it won't compete with the profession quality product put out by professional studios.

 

I think that is the sound you are searching for, and you would do better to save your money for the better quality items.

 

 

On a side note, if you are planning on making money doing this, you may already have pro (or semi pro) studios in your area. You have the talent and they have the equipment. So you spend $500 in the studio and get paid $600 from your client, you made $100. As long as you make more than you spend, you are a success.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thankyou both for your advice. Its nice to get some different opinions because in other forums people are saying different stuff.

 

The best advice I've heard so far is sell the m-audio

 

Get the usbpre2 http://www.sounddevices.com/products/usbpre2.htm

 

Then spend $400 on a mic

 

Does this sound like good advice? I'm literally going to be broke after this so that's why it's important for me to make the right decision.

 

Here is a link to a video i did with my commentary and rapping. What would be a good mic for my vocals????

 

Or should i avoid this advice altogether.

 

I understand about the treatment of the room but I I'm not going to be spending any money on that since i use a closet with eggshell foam mattress topper on the walls. Im not buying anything more with that just need info on the other stuff

 

Thanks guys I really really do appreciate all the help

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.apogeedigital.com/products/duet2.php

 

I seriously think you should save your money and work with what Logic has to offer. Follow lagerfeldt's advice on the EQ and Compression ( etc... ).

 

BTW - look him up ... http://www.popmusic.dk/references.html

 

If I were you, I would take his advice over most any forum you have been on - cuz he has skillz and a reputation.

 

Develop your skills with what you already have.

 

You could buy all the expensive equipment in the world, but if you don't know how to make it work for you, you will end up frustrated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The best advice I've heard so far is sell the m-audio

I don't think you're really taking in the advice here, but that's okay of course. We all make mistakes and learn from them the hard way.

 

I see you're making another very related post on this forum:

http://www.logicprohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=77228

 

I'm not David (who runs this forum), but I recommend that you keep your related questions to one single thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sorry agerfeldt

Well i want to spoil myself and get something new. I decided on getting the SM7B mic and the RME babyface audio device

 

Its kind of hard to get good eq and compression settings with the setup i have now

 

the sound quality raw literally sounds ugly. It doesn't even sound like me it sounds like it was dipped in mud. you probably have nice equipment, but the way it sounds right now is discusting. I have to mess with the eq a lot and and compression and its still hard to get good results because the original audio is so horrible

 

With a new setup it will at least give me something good to start off with i can practice and better eq and compression techniques without completely wasting my time on crappy audio that will probably still come out crappy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I really do appreciate the info and about the importance of the acoustic treatment

Since the sm7b is a dynamic and Cardioid (unidirectional) it isn't affected as much by having bad acoustic treatment. ( you won't notice it as much) and I think i fi add this thing in the pic it will help out and fix that problem or greatly improve it

 

Am i wrong again or would i waste my money on that thing

http://img824.imageshack.us/img824/8360/boxwithmic2.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the sound quality raw literally sounds ugly. It doesn't even sound like me it sounds like it was dipped in mud. you probably have nice equipment, but the way it sounds right now is discusting. I have to mess with the eq a lot and and compression and its still hard to get good results because the original audio is so horrible.

You're missing the point: buying any new equipment won't fix your problem if you have acoustic problems in your room.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're missing the point: buying any new equipment won't fix your problem if you have acoustic problems in your room.

 

so your saying if I buy this equipment its going to sound exactly the same because of the room treatment?

 

I don't need it super super professional quality i just want better quality than i have now

 

And the mic is 1 way directional and with the thing behind it that should help a lot right??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

O ok so it would make no difference at all and not even help a little with that foam thing behind the mic?

Treating my room sounds really expensive plus would look funny

I don't have any extra rooms in my house because my daughter is in the other room.

I used to record my music in the closet with foam on the wall and the sound was 1,000 times better than in the open room.

Its been years since i made a song and you reminded me of the importance of it

When i do my commentaries I have to watch the video while I talk so I have to do it in the open room but I am also saving up for a tablet I can bring in the closet with me so I can see the video and record the commentary (thanks to your advice)

My closet is at the edge of my house so it is shaped like a triangle

the left wall is straight up but the ceiling goes to a point and slants down to the carpet on the right side kind of like in the picture but a smaller space and no window

Is this actually better than a normal square room?

 

And my final choice on what I'm buying is the http://www.focusrite.com/products/mic_pres/isa_one_digital/

 

It has digital output which means I can sell my m-audio and hook it up directly to my iMacs digital input.

 

P.S. will plugging it directly to my iMacs input make it higher quality than usb or firewire, or worse?

 

Once again thanks

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-dvKC4OcgTys/ToAIK4ZIK5I/AAAAAAAAWFE/IO3n8FjB6XA/s1600/architizer+triangle+room+3.jpg[/img]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...